Micron-scale electro-acoustic qubit architecture for FTQC

"Building a fault-tolerant quantum computer using concatenated cat codes"

Published by Christopher Chamberland, Kyungjoo Noh, Patricio Arrangoiz-Arriola, Earl T. Campbell, Connor T. Hann, Joseph Iverson, Harald Putterman, Thomas C. Bohdanowicz, Steven T. Flammia, Andrew Keller, Gil Refael, John Preskill, Liang Jiang, Amir H. Safavi-Naeini, Oskar Painter, Fernando G.S.L. Brandão (Amazon AWS  & IQIM), 13th December 2020

Error correction
Quantum hardware
Micron-scale electro-acoustic qubit architecture for FTQC

In this paper, researchers from Amazon AWS & IQIM present an architecture for a fault-tolerant quantum computer, that is based on hybrid acoustic-electro devices to implement a stabilized cat code with highly biased noise, dominated by dephasing. To combat these sources of noise, they concatenated the cat code with an outer code that focuses mostly on correcting the dephasing errors, based on the repetition code and the surface code. The assumed error model is critical, since it will affect the fidelities of all required operations (initialization, measurement, gates, etc.) based on which the results are compared to previous works. Therefore, a detailed error analysis of measurements and gates, including CNOT and Toffoli gates is presented according to this realistic noise model.

Fault-tolerant quantum computing requires a universal set of gates, which can be divided into two categories, namely gates that belong to the Clifford group and gates that do not. Clifford gates can be typically achieved easily for a variety of codes, however non-Clifford gates require sophisticated protocols to create and then purify to increase their fidelity, like the magic state preparation/distillation protocol. A novel magic-state distillation protocol for Toffoli states is introduced here (injected via lattice surgery), which in combination with the error correction techniques that were used, result in a lower overhead compared to previous works. Actually, it is estimated that the factory that generates the magic states only accounts for approximately 7% of the total resource overhead requirements, with the other 93% coming from the rotated surface code.

In terms of quantum advantage, the authors find that with around 1,000 superconducting circuit components, one could construct a fault-tolerant quantum computer that can run circuits which are intractable for classical supercomputers.

However, when comparing this work to other related works, one should keep in mind that the assumed gate fidelities and the assumed error model can greatly affect the presented results. The error model in this work assumes Z error rates that are far less optimistic than typically assumed for transmon qubits and due to the cat state encoding there is bit-flip noise suppression that can naturally lead to increased performance. Furthermore, transmon architecture resource estimates are based on a simple depolarizing noise model, whereas this noise model has been derived from first principles modeling of the hardware, making the analysis more realistic.

Moreover, the authors claim to have a comparable or up to 3 times fewer qubits required compared to other superconducting transmon qubit architectures, based on the assumed gate fidelities. Also, similar runtime figures are reported compared to other superconducting transmon qubit architectures, however an important distinction of this protocol is that the magic states are created slightly faster than they can be transported to the main algorithm, whereas in other architectures the main algorithm has to wait for the magic states to be created which is a bottleneck in the runtime.

Although such a protocol shows promise for fault-tolerant quantum computing, the injection of magic states comes with an additional qubit cost for data access and routing. The choice of routing solution leads to a lower bound on runtime execution, so more careful optimization of routing costs and speed of magic state injection is crucial.